Great Britain's oldest renewable energy projects are expected to claim nearly £9bn in subsidies next year because of soaring market prices, independent analysis has found. Renewable energy projects built between 2003 and 2014 are forecast to receive £4.5bn in subsidies over the next financial year, on top of £4.2bn earned from wholesale market revenue, according to research by the Energy Competitiveness Unit, a non-partisan research and policy project. This represents almost 50% more than developers received before Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine sent gas prices soaring in 2022. Almost a third of the UK's wind and solar farms that rely on the government's legacy renewables subsidy scheme are in line for these soaring payments.
The issue stems from how the legacy support system works. Unlike newer renewable energy projects that earn fixed-price subsidies, older projects access support via the renewables obligation scheme, which provides payments on top of what developers earn from the wholesale market. This means that higher gas market prices automatically trigger higher subsidy costs for renewables. The scheme was credited with kickstarting the UK's renewable energy industry when introduced almost 25 years ago, but the Energy Competitiveness Unit said it 'has been allowed to persist unsustainably'. Andrew O'Brien, the unit's director, told the Guardian that the rise in wholesale prices means many developers are earning 'well above what they could reasonably have expected' when they first invested in these projects.
The government has already begun attempting to address the issue. Last year it announced plans to remove three-quarters of the scheme's costs from home energy bills and move these levies into general taxation from April 2026. The government has also warned that legacy generators could face higher windfall taxes unless they abandon the existing scheme in favour of a new partially fixed subsidy contract. In his budget speech last month, Chancellor John Healey said the government would 'further break the grip of international gas prices on our bills by moving more of our old renewables on to fixed-price contracts.'
The Energy Competitiveness Unit argues the government's proposals do not go far enough. It has proposed an alternative where all generators would move to entirely fixed-price contracts, which it calls a fair value contract for difference. This arrangement would cut electricity costs by £3.8bn next year and £9.2bn over 10 years, the unit claims. Such contracts could also offer legal protection against future political risk, the analysis suggests, referencing concerns raised by Reform UK about potential dismantling of renewable energy support.
Tara Singh, chief executive of RenewableUK, countered that renewable projects remain beneficial to consumers. She noted that according to research by University College London, wind power has saved consumers £100bn since 2010 even when accounting for support schemes like the renewables obligation by reducing the need for expensive imports. She highlighted that renewable energy projects using the scheme now pay windfall tax to the Treasury at a rate of up to 80p of every additional pound earned from market prices above £82.61 per megawatt hour. The average wholesale price of electricity over the last 12 months exceeded £100 per megawatt hour, she said.
For UK energy bill payers and businesses, this means the debate over how to reform old renewable energy subsidies will directly affect electricity costs, while renewable energy generators face decisions about whether to accept new contract terms or face higher taxation on windfall profits from volatile global gas markets.
