National Savings & Investments has recovered £518,000 in Premium Bond prize money that was mistakenly paid out to savers' Direct Saver accounts because of a technical error. The blunder affected approximately 3,500 savers following May's prize draw. NS&I said it contacted all affected account holders, apologised for the inconvenience and cancelled the duplicate payments. However, £1,600 of the total overpayment still needs to be repaid by customers.
Some of the wrongly distributed prize money was automatically recovered from affected accounts, but NS&I temporarily blocked transactions on some savers' accounts while the duplicate amounts were removed. One customer told The Times that after legitimately winning £1,700, he was overpaid an additional £325 and his account access was frozen until the money was recovered. Under UK law, savers do not have the right to keep money that was incorrectly paid to them, though recoveries should not push accounts into debt.
Scott Dixon, of The Complaints Resolver, told This is Money that although NS&I is legally entitled to recover mistakenly paid funds, customers should not suffer unfairly due to the bank's error. He said NS&I should offer affordable interest-free repayment options and consider goodwill compensation, particularly because savers who believed they had legitimately won money were unlikely to question the payment and may have already spent it.
This incident is the latest in a series of operational failures at NS&I. In March, the bank discovered that approximately £475million belonging to 37,500 deceased customers had not been handed to their families due to failures in its search process. By this month, NS&I revised its estimate downward to just under 30,300 estates with a value of up to £181.9million that may be affected. The scandal led to the resignation of former chief executive Dax Harkins, who was replaced by Sir Jim Harra, the former head of HM Revenue & Customs.
In June 2023, NS&I made a separate error involving interest payments, where 3,265 savers received an extra £600 each by mistake due to incorrect interest rates. In that case, those who received overpayments were not required to repay the money. NS&I holds £240billion for 24million savers and operates the monthly Premium Bonds prize lottery, which awards prizes ranging from £25 to £1million.
For savers and Premium Bond holders, the error means that some may face unexpected demands to repay money they believed they had legitimately won, potentially creating financial difficulty if they have already spent the funds.
